rune adopt finalize currently commits the complete block-review ledger as .provenance/review.yaml. A composite skill with 194 parsed blocks produced a 1,668-line record, including repeated file-level notes on every block.
The user requirement is to review imports block by block. It does not require permanent provenance per block. Block IDs, intermediate digests, verdict timestamps, and transport metadata are workflow state. They should remain in the temporary adoption session.
Published provenance should retain source-level facts only:
- pinned upstream URI and revision
- upstream digest and license or attribution data
- final subject paths and digests
- reviewer and completion time
- concise adaptation summary
- exceptional cuts or attribution requirements when relevant
rune adopt doctor must not warn that a valid source-level provenance sidecar lacks a committed review ledger. Finalization should delete or archive session state outside the adopted artifact instead of placing review.yaml in the deck. Existing review ledgers need a migration or compaction command.
rune adopt finalizecurrently commits the complete block-review ledger as.provenance/review.yaml. A composite skill with 194 parsed blocks produced a 1,668-line record, including repeated file-level notes on every block.The user requirement is to review imports block by block. It does not require permanent provenance per block. Block IDs, intermediate digests, verdict timestamps, and transport metadata are workflow state. They should remain in the temporary adoption session.
Published provenance should retain source-level facts only:
rune adopt doctormust not warn that a valid source-level provenance sidecar lacks a committed review ledger. Finalization should delete or archive session state outside the adopted artifact instead of placingreview.yamlin the deck. Existing review ledgers need a migration or compaction command.