Make approval provenance auditable - #39
Conversation
Require pre-Compile read-backs to distinguish attempted, failed, denied, and successful actions. This prevents a semantic approval from contradicting its retained tool ledger while keeping First Draft, Compile, and Publication effects separate.
|
Post-merge review, hosted CI green. This PR required pre-Compile read-backs to report every attempted tool or What survived is the good part: the principle that a claimed observation must trace to a retained successful No action needed; noting the supersession so a reader of this diff does not implement against it. |
|
This PR added heavyweight auditability to an agent approval flow, and most of it was rolled back within a The intent was sound. When an agent claims "I inspected the staged Plan and here is its semantic model," you Why it did not hold: completeness requirements scale badly. "Report every attempted tool or command" turns The transferable rule: audit claims, not activity. Demand evidence for each assertion the decision actually |
Summary
Verification