docs: add BIP research inventory - #2
Conversation
vitrixLab
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
GE / RAV — Test Drive on Forked BIP Research PR
Scope: comment/review evidence surface only.
Observed before this test:
- Issue/conversation comments: 0
- Inline review threads: 0
- PR #2 is open and draft.
- PR description identifies this as a fork-only research inventory and states that no upstream contribution is implied.
Evidence boundary
This test deliberately distinguishes:
CLAIM ≠ VALIDATION ≠ ACCEPTANCE ≠ AUTHORIZATION
The research inventory's descriptive claims are treated as claims unless independently supported by repository, document-content, test, CI, or other direct evidence.
A clean comment/thread surface does not certify the underlying inventory, methodology, completeness, correctness, or upstream acceptance.
GE result
PASS — INFORMATIONAL / EVIDENCE-BOUNDARY TEST
No blocking security or governance finding is established by the comment/review surface examined in this test.
Important: this PASS is limited to the reviewed evidence surface. It does not imply merge authorization, upstream acceptance, research correctness, or certification of the inventory.
RAV principle:
CLAIM ≠ VALIDATION ≠ ACCEPTANCE ≠ AUTHORIZATION
vitrixLab
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
JARVIS RAV — GOVERNANCE READINESS
STATUS: PASS — GOVERNANCE ONLY
Scope: fork-level governance/evidence readiness of this BIP research PR; not certification of the underlying research claims.
The PR is a draft fork-level artifact, targets the fork's master branch, and explicitly marks missing body-derived metrics as UNKNOWN. It also states that the BIP-445 request is a research target not present in the current master tree.
No governance blocker is identified from the reviewed PR surface.
PASS does not imply upstream Bitcoin BIPs acceptance, maintainer approval, research correctness, or merge authorization.
RAV:
CLAIM ≠ VALIDATION ≠ ACCEPTANCE ≠ AUTHORIZATION
Quantitative/qualitative BIP research inventory in the fork. Draft only. No upstream contribution implied.
master(182.mediawiki, 6.md)UNKNOWNmastertree